PlanetSMS Blog

Why did eBay remove my eBook?

 

You have written your very 1st eBook, you have created a killer sales page and you list your eBook on eBay. Your eBook starts to sell and your excitement builds at the prospect of 100s of dollars in your PayPal account, then bang! EBay end your auction for a violation of terms. Now you feel like giving up.

The 1st thing to do is not to panic as this happens a lot. I have had many listings ended over the years for silly policy violations. Anyone who has been a subscriber of mine for a long time will remember I had my $10,000 auction eBook ended when I had only sold half of my inventory. The reason eBay ended my auction was because I said I accept 'cash at your own risk'. This is a big no no with eBay but at the time I never realised it.

Anyway, this has got me thinking of the most common reasons eBay will pull one of your eBook auctions.

  1. Wrong, category. EBooks must be listed in the
    Everything else > Information products category. List them anywhere else and eBay will eventually catch up with you and remove the offending item(s).
     

  2. Not stating you are the copyright holder. If you have created your own eBook you are the copyright holder and you must let eBay know this in your listing. Just a simple statement at the end of your auction, something like "Note to eBay staff, I am the copyright holder of this item" will do.
     

  3. Not stating you are licensed to sell the eBook you are selling. ebay.com's downloadable media policy states you must be the owner (copyright holder) or authorized to distribute the downloadable product by the intellectual property owner. (This means you have resale rights)

    You should let eBay know this in your listing(s) so it's best to state something along the lines of "Note to eBay staff, I am licensed to sell this product". You can also use the following statement if the material used is from the public domain (freely available) "Note to eBay staff, the underlying material is in the public domain".

     

  4. Misleading title. Make sure your title accurately describes the item you are selling and does not mislead. EG, 'Make a million dollars in a day' is a misleading title.
     

  5. Keyword and trademark violation. Try to avoid using keywords that are not related to the product you are selling. EG, If you were selling a weight loss eBook don't include the names of famous diet plans. This can also apply to the trademark violation rule.
     

  6. Selling a lot of 1p/1c eBooks. If you sell only 1 cent eBooks you will eventually get suspended, eBay don't like it as it is seen as feedback solicitation. The same goes for buying nothing but 1 cent eBooks. You will end up suspended so don't risk your account. If you want proof just look at the 'no longer a registered user' in the feedback profile of any 1 cent seller. Unless you want to join them don't do it.
     

  7. Selling copyrighted material. This goes without saying. If you have any doubts about an eBook don't sell it. Always double check any eBooks you sell actually have resale rights and can be sold on eBay.


I could go on but from emails I receive from fellow eBook sellers the above reasons seem to be the most common. Just remember that there is never a guarantee your listings will never be ended as there are so many eBay policies and in fact the rules differ slightly for each country. The US users have it best as they have a 'digital item' format for selling. The sooner this goes worldwide the better as this will stop a lot of problems as it will give eBook sellers the recognition they deserve. Take note eBay UK.

So what should I do if eBay end one of my auctions?

The most important thing is you shouldn't relist the offending item till you clear things up with eBay 1st. Find out why eBay have ended your item, this may take time as eBay usually send pre-written responses and it can sometimes take 2-3 emails to get a proper answer. Just don't give up and you will get to the root of the problem. Also try and keep things polite as the person at the other end is not the person who ended your listing so there is no need to have a go at them.

Once you find out why your listing was ended make adjustments to your sales page and and get the all clear from eBay. This is crucial, just get eBay to check out your sales page and let you know if everything is ok. I usually just re-list the offending item that I have corrected and contact customer support to get the all clear. Once you get the go ahead you are free to re-list and this also keeps you in eBay's good books as they can see you are making an effort not to break their rules.

I know getting listings ended can be very frustrating and believe me I have been there but at the end of the day we have to abide by eBay's rules and as long as you correct any violations when notified by eBay you should have no further problems.

serrebro
good luck next time.
Jun-04-07 03:31:19 PDT Report this comment
gingerbreadbabies
I had eBay remove one of the ebooks that I had for sale. It was titled 101 Fun Feedbacks. I guess their system saw the word feedback in the title and they took it down. It wasn't a misleading title, but you do have to be careful as to what you put in your titles. Listen to this guy - he sure knows what he is talking about!
Jun-05-07 19:11:07 PDT Report this comment
stevedav
John, you save everyone so much time, it is great to see that you are prepared to blaze the trial that so many think is not possible.
You are really and inspiration for peopleto get of there rear end and make ebooks pay. I really solely on ebooks to make my living and a lot of it is from tips you share so willingly.
This ebook listing guide should be taken by anyone wishing to make money online and printed out and used as a check guide.
My newphen is staying with us at present and read one of Johns books and has seen the money I make and is noe writing an ebook on How To Get a Flying Job in Botswanna. So you see any subject is possible.

Keep it up John.

Cheers Steve Davidson
Jun-08-07 20:33:39 PDT Report this comment
jimco828
John, I have to say that You, Sir, Are one of the "Great Ones' that I am planning and modeling my ebook business after. I have been a long time subscriber to your newsletters and I have been studying your methods and attempting to follow in your footsteps towards my own success. I hope that one day I will be as Great As You Are in this field. Thank You Sir For Everything That You Do.

Osborne Walles
Jimco Enterprises
Jun-09-07 13:23:26 PDT Report this comment
antipodeanplus
Hi John,

I noticed that you said it was the way you list your books. I have turbolister and when I put things in the book category it has a digital delivery format option.
Later I also noticed that in the business category it has e-books.
I am not really sure If books with digital delivery is wrong.So I mix up my listings. I only had one removed as i didn't state I had reseller rights.
As for 1 cent books , yes I just learnt that lesson today as an auction. I won't do that again.
Thanks for all your help i must keep at this addictive business.

Antipodean Plus Ebooks
Hilary
Jun-12-07 00:10:44 PDT Report this comment
treasuresgoround
Another great post.

I know of a seller that just got suspended for the feedback violation rule.
Jun-27-07 12:17:18 PDT Report this comment
breakneckauctions
Yes I just had a listing removed yesterday for violating one of ebay's lising conditions (accidentally) I didn't just relist the item immediately until I made sure I fixed the problem. While it may seem easy to just create an ebook and list it on eBay you really have to be careful about a lot of things. Although there are some times when you follow the rules to a T and yet ebay still finds fault with some of your auctions. Crazy!
Aug-08-07 14:21:19 PDT Report this comment
empoweringebooks2
I wish I read this before I began my eBook selling business! After I finished a few of my ebooks knowing points 2 & 3 before hand would have saved me a lot of trouble! Great post John. hopefully a lot of new ebook sellers will find this!
Sep-14-07 10:56:18 PDT Report this comment
designrebels
John,
Great Info .Great advice ..Best of luck and i hope to follow in your foot steps!
Best wishes & Kind regards,
Ben
Jan-17-08 12:05:34 PST Report this comment
msl662
I had an ebook listing removed and I didnt know I was in violation of a policy. Effective 3/2008 all digital downloads have to now be listed in classified ads. Of course I didnt know it at the time, so now when you list it in classified ads, feedback can't be exchanged between seller & buyer. I think thats unfortunate because feedback is such a huge part of ebay. My feedback is from my ebay store. But I am also selling ebooks which I'm finding out are becoming very profitable!

Thanks again John for such an informative and educational blog. : )
May-18-08 12:06:13 PDT Report this comment

About eBay | Announcements | Security Center | eBay Toolbar | Policies | Government Relations | Site Map | Help
Copyright © 1995-2008 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Designated trademarks and brands are the property of their respective owners. Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the eBay User Agreement and Privacy Policy.
eBay official time